HomeMy WebLinkAboutBowman SurveyJohn – see below. We are working our way through this. Call me when you
get a chance. Dave
<mailto:http://www.cityofcapecanaveral.org/>
Launch your connection…
<mailto:https://www.facebook.com/CityofCapeCanaveral>
<mailto:https://www.instagram.com/cityofcapecanaveral/>
<mailto:https://www.linkedin.com/company/city-of-cape-canaveral-the>
<mailto:https://twitter.com/CapeCanaveralFL>
From: Anthony A. Garganese [mailto:agarganese@orlandolaw.net]
Sent: Friday, November 18, 2016 3:06 PM
To: David Greene <D.Greene@cityofcapecanaveral.org>; David Dickey
<D.Dickey@cityofcapecanaveral.org>; Jim Beadle (jim@sbmlawyers.com)
<jim@sbmlawyers.com>
Subject: FW: Oak Lane Variance Request 11/22/16
From: Douglas W. Ackerman [mailto:dwa@kirwinnorris.com]
Sent: Friday, November 18, 2016 2:35 PM
To: cocoabeach123@aol.com <mailto:cocoabeach123@aol.com> ;
m.goforth@cityofcapecanaveral.org
<mailto:m.goforth@cityofcapecanaveral.org> ; Anthony A. Garganese
<agarganese@orlandolaw.net <mailto:agarganese@orlandolaw.net> >; Paul
deVivero <paul@geodatafl.com <mailto:paul@geodatafl.com> >; Danielle M.
Reyes <DMR@kirwinnorris.com <mailto:DMR@kirwinnorris.com> >
Cc: , "terrilynbowman@yahoo.com <kathryn.l.seidel@gmail.com>;
terrilynbowman@yahoo.com; asrapp@aol.com; moealdenj@bellsouth.net;
A.Binney@cityofcapecanaveral.org; Angela Raymond <angray8@aol.com>;
Raymond <doug7048@inbox.com>; D.Alexander@cityofcapecanaveral.org;
E.Lawson@cityofcapecanaveral.org; evanfla@gmail.com; Alicia Spring
<asrapp@aol.com>; moealdenj@bellsouth.net; Angela Raymond
<angray8@aol.com>; ,
<mailto:terrilynbowman@yahoo.com%20%3ckathryn.l.seidel@gmail.com%3e;%20t
errilynbowman@yahoo.com;%20asrapp@aol.com;%20moealdenj@bellsouth.net;%20
A.Binney@cityofcapecanaveral.org;%20Angela%20Raymond%20%3cangray8@aol.co
m%3e;%20Raymond%20%3cdoug7048@inbox.com%3e;%20D.Alexander@cityofcapecana
veral.org;%20E.Lawson@cityofcapecanaveral.org;%20evanfla@gmail.com;%20Al
icia%20Spring%20%3casrapp@aol.com%3e;%20moealdenj@bellsouth.net;%20Angel
a%20Raymond%20%3cangray8@aol.com%3e;%20,%20> "Barry S. <rvoeilau@aol.com
<mailto:rvoeilau@aol.com> >; bnienstadt@cfl.rr.com
<mailto:bnienstadt@cfl.rr.com> ; s <chartley@cfl.rr.com
<mailto:chartley@cfl.rr.com> >; Raymond <doug7048@inbox.com
<mailto:doug7048@inbox.com> >; evanfla@gmail.com
<mailto:evanfla@gmail.com> ; Gene Petre <gcpetre@aol.com
<mailto:gcpetre@aol.com> >; George Sweetman (pattygirl2010@live.com
<mailto:pattygirl2010@live.com> <pattygirl2010@live.com
<mailto:pattygirl2010@live.com> >; harrymp@cfl.rr.com
<mailto:harrymp@cfl.rr.com> ; jaltruda@aol.com <mailto:jaltruda@aol.com>
Subject: Oak Lane Variance Request 11/22/16
Dear Ladies and Gentlemen:
I have the privilege of representing Terri Bowman’s
whose limited liability company owns lot A26 in the City of Cape
Canaveral. Even though she is an entirely innocent purchaser, Ms.
Bowman has done what those who are truly responsible should have done:
She has had the entirety of Oak Lane surveyed together with the adjacent
lots by a licensed professional surveyor and mapper. Attached please
find the results. We will be presenting the signed and sealed copies at
the hearing on lot A25’s application for a variance on Tuesday night,
November 22, 2016.
The following is readily apparent from the survey:
1. The application for variance cannot be granted for numerous
reasons among which are (1) the house is grossly in violation of the
front setback of 25 feet, and (2) the house is actually on the side
property line and grossly in violation of the side setback. Please be
advised that whatever surveys have been provided to the City to show a
“slanted” side setback in an attempt to get the variance are not based
on any instruments recorded in the public records of Brevard County.
They should therefore be ignored.
2. The house on lot A25 should never receive a Certificate of
Occupancy as it is in flagrant violation of the City’s code of
ordinances.
3. We believe that there could be resolutions to the
issues with respect to Lot 25, but they must be undertaken in a proper
and legal (recorded) way that also resolves similar issues for the
remaining lots on Oak Lane.
4. We will be pursuing all legal avenues to protect my client’s
rights.
5. Please note that we will require adequate time at Tuesday’s hearing
to present these issues to the Board, consistent with Due Process.
Thank you for your consideration.
Douglas W. Ackerman | Partner
Board Certified in Construction Law by the Florida Bar
Kirwin Norris, P.A.
15 W. Church Street
Suite 301
Orlando, Florida 32801
O: 407-740-6600
F: 407-740-6363
E: dwa@kirwinnorris.com <mailto:dwa@kirwinnorris.com>
<https://www.facebook.com/KirwinNorris>
<http://www.linkedin.com/company/kirwin-norris>
<http://www.kirwinnorris.com/>
This email message including attachments, if any, is intended for the
use of the individual or entity named above and may contain
attorney-client confidential and/or privileged information. If the
reader of this message is not the intended recipient, you are hereby
notified that any review, use, disclosure, copying, or distribution is
strictly prohibited. If you have received this email message in error,
please contact the sender by reply email and destroy all copies of the
original message including attachments. Thank you.
Pursuant to federal regulations imposed on practitioners who render tax
advice ("Circular 230"), we are required to advise you that any tax
advice contained herein is not intended or written to be used for the
purpose of avoiding tax penalties that may be imposed by the Internal
Revenue Service. If this advice is or is intended to be used or
referred to in promoting, marketing or recommending a partnership or
other entity, investment plan or arrangement, the regulations under
Circular 230 require that we advise you as follows: (1) this writing is
not intended or written to be used, and it cannot be used, for the
purpose of avoiding tax penalties that may be imposed on a taxpayer; (2)
the advice was written to support the promotion or marketing of the
transaction(s) or matter(s) addressed by the written advice; and (3) the
taxpayer should seek advice based on the taxpayer's particular
circumstances from an independent tax advisor.
Florida has a very broad public records law. As a result, any written
communication created or received by the City of Cape Canaveral
officials and employees will be made available to the public and/or
media upon request, unless otherwise exempt. Under Florida Law, email
addresses are public records. If you do not want your email address
released in response to a public-records request, do not send electronic
email to this entity. Instead, contact our office by phone or in writing
Florida has a very broad public records law. As a result, any written
communication created or received by the City of Cape Canaveral
officials and employees will be made available to the public and/or
media upon request, unless otherwise exempt. Under Florida Law, email
addresses are public records. If you do not want your email address
released in response to a public-records request, do not send electronic
email to this entity. Instead, contact our office by phone or in writing
瑨汭慴㙧‴瀼挠慬獳∽獍乯牯慭≬紾桜浴牬晴笠桜浴牬晴‰屻尪瑨汭慴ㅧ㠴㰠灳湡猠祴敬∽潣潬㩲ㄣ㑆㜹≄紾桜浴牬晴笠桜浴牬晴‰屻尪瑨汭慴㡧‴渦獢㭰屽瑨汭瑲❜ち桜浴牬晴‰屻尪瑨汭慴㡧‴渦獢㭰屽瑨汭瑲❜ち桜浴牬晴‰屻尪瑨汭慴㡧‴渦獢㭰屽瑨汭瑲❜ち桜浴牬晴‰屻尪瑨汭慴㡧‴渦獢㭰屽瑨汭瑲❜ち桜浴牬晴‰屻尪瑨汭慴㡧‴渦獢㭰屽瑨汭瑲❜ち桜浴牬晴‰屻尪瑨汭慴㡧‴渦獢㭰屽瑨汭瑲❜ち桜浴牬晴‰屻
尪瑨汭慴㡧‴渦獢㭰屽瑨汭瑲❜ち桜浴牬晴‰屻尪瑨汭慴㡧‴渦獢㭰屽瑨汭瑲❜ち桜浴牬晴‰屻尪瑨汭慴㡧‴渦獢㭰屽瑨汭瑲❜ち桜浴牬晴‰屻尪瑨汭慴㡧‴渦獢㭰屽瑨汭瑲❜ち桜浴牬晴‰屻尪瑨汭慴㡧‴渦獢㭰屽瑨汭瑲❜ち桜浴牬晴‰屻尪瑨汭慴ㅧ㘵㰠猯慰㹮屽瑨汭瑲屽瑨汭瑲てഠ笊⩜桜浴瑬条㐱‸猼慰瑳汹㵥挢汯牯⌺䙆㌳㤹㸢屽瑨汭瑲屻瑨汭瑲て䰠畡据൨笊⩜桜浴瑬条㐸㰠㹩屽瑨汭瑲屻桜浴牬晴‰礠畯൲笊⩜桜
浴瑬条‴灜牡素桜浴牬晴†桜浴牬晴‰屻尪瑨汭慴㥧′⼼㹩屽瑨汭瑲屽瑨汭瑲て挠湯敮瑣潩൮笊⩜桜浴瑬条㐸☠㠣㌲㬰屽瑨汭瑲❜㔸桜浴牬晴‰屻尪瑨汭慴ㅧ㘵㰠猯慰㹮屽瑨汭瑲屽瑨汭瑲てഠ笊⩜桜浴瑬条㐸㰠牨晥∽慭汩潴栺瑴獰⼺眯睷昮捡扥潯潣⽭楃祴景慃数慃慮敶慲≬紾桜浴牬晴笠晜敩摬屻尪汦楤獮筴奈䕐䱒义⁋洢楡瑬㩯瑨灴㩳⼯睷慦散潢歯挮浯䌯瑩潹䍦灡䍥湡癡牥污索筽晜摬獲瑬捜ㅦ畜桜浴牬晴‰屻尪瑨汭慴ㅧ㠴㰠灳湡
猠祴敬∽潣潬㩲〣㘵䌳㬱整瑸搭捥牯瑡潩㩮潮敮㸢屽瑨汭瑲屻瑨汭瑲てഠ笊⩜桜浴瑬条㐸㰠浩潢摲牥∽∰眠摩桴∽㈳•敨杩瑨∽㈳•摩∽楐瑣牵彥へ㈰弰∷猠捲∽楣㩤浩条づ㘰瀮杮䐱㐲䈱⹃䘱䑂䌱〳•污㵴昢捡≥紾屻尪瑨汭慴ㅧ㘵㰠猯慰㹮屽瑨汭瑲屽瑨汭瑲て尠瑨汭瑲屽瑨汭瑲て尠瑨汭瑲屽瑨汭瑲てഠ笊⩜桜浴瑬条㈹㰠愯紾屻尪瑨汭慴㡧‴愼栠敲㵦洢楡瑬㩯瑨灴㩳⼯睷湩瑳条慲潣⽭楣祴景慣数慣慮敶慲⽬㸢屽瑨汭瑲屻楦汥筤
⩜晜摬湩瑳䡻偙剅䥌䭎∠慭汩潴栺瑴獰⼺眯睷椮獮慴牧浡挮浯振瑩潹捦灡捥湡癡牥污∯絽屻汦牤汳屴晣就汵尠瑨汭瑲てഠ笊⩜桜浴瑬条㐱‸猼慰瑳汹㵥挢汯牯⌺㔰㌶ㅃ琻硥敤潣慲楴湯渺湯≥紾桜浴牬晴笠桜浴牬晴‰屻尪瑨汭慴㡧‴椼杭戠牯敤㵲〢•楷瑤㵨㌢∲栠楥桧㵴㌢∲椠㵤倢捩畴敲硟〰〲㙟•牳㵣挢摩椺慭敧〰⸷湰䁧㉄ㄴ䍂ㄮ䉆ㅄ㍃∰愠瑬∽湩瑳≡紾屻尪瑨汭慴ㅧ㘵㰠猯慰㹮屽瑨汭瑲屽瑨汭瑲て尠瑨汭瑲屽瑨汭瑲て尠瑨汭瑲屽
瑨汭瑲てഠ笊⩜桜浴瑬条㈹㰠愯紾屻尪瑨汭慴㡧‴愼栠敲㵦洢楡瑬㩯瑨灴㩳⼯睷楬歮摥湩挮浯振浯慰祮振瑩景挭灡ⵥ慣慮敶慲桴≥紾桜浴牬晴笠晜敩摬屻尪汦楤獮筴奈䕐䱒义⁋洢楡瑬㩯瑨灴㩳⼯睷楬歮摥湩挮浯振浯慰祮振瑩景挭灡ⵥ慣慮敶慲桴≥絽屻汦牤汳屴晣就汵尠瑨汭瑲てഠ笊⩜桜浴瑬条㐱‸猼慰瑳汹㵥挢汯牯⌺㔰㌶ㅃ琻硥敤潣慲楴湯渺湯≥紾桜浴牬晴笠桜浴牬晴‰屻尪瑨汭慴㡧‴椼杭戠牯敤㵲〢•楷瑤㵨㌢∲栠楥桧㵴㌢
∲椠㵤倢捩畴敲硟〰〲㑟•牳㵣挢摩椺慭敧〰⸸湰䁧㉄ㄴ䍂ㄮ䉆ㅄ㍃∰愠瑬∽楌歮㸢ൽ笊⩜桜浴瑬条㔱‶⼼灳湡紾桜浴牬晴素桜浴牬晴‰桜浴牬晴素桜浴牬晴‰桜浴牬晴素桜浴牬晴‰屻尪瑨汭慴㥧′⼼㹡ൽ笊⩜桜浴瑬条㐸㰠牨晥∽慭汩潴栺瑴獰⼺琯楷瑴牥挮浯䌯灡䍥湡癡牥污䱆㸢屽瑨汭瑲屻楦汥筤⩜晜摬湩瑳䡻偙剅䥌䭎∠慭汩潴栺瑴獰⼺琯楷瑴牥挮浯䌯灡䍥湡癡牥污䱆索筽晜摬獲瑬捜ㅦ畜桜浴牬晴‰屻尪瑨汭慴ㅧ㠴㰠灳湡猠祴敬∽潣潬
㩲〣㘵䌳㬱整瑸搭捥牯瑡潩㩮潮敮㸢屽瑨汭瑲屻瑨汭瑲てഠ笊⩜桜浴瑬条㐸㰠浩潢摲牥∽∰眠摩桴∽㈳•敨杩瑨∽㈳•摩∽楐瑣牵彥へ㈰弰∵猠捲∽楣㩤浩条づ㤰瀮杮䐱㐲䈱⹃䘱䑂䌱〳•污㵴琢楷≴紾屻尪瑨汭慴ㅧ㘵㰠猯慰㹮屽瑨汭瑲屽瑨汭瑲て尠瑨汭瑲屽瑨汭瑲て尠瑨汭瑲屽瑨汭瑲てഠ笊⩜桜浴瑬条㈹㰠愯紾屻尪瑨汭慴ㅧ㠴㰠灳湡猠祴敬∽潣潬㩲ㄣ㑆㜹≄紾桜浴牬晴笠桜浴牬晴‰屻尪瑨汭慴㉧㐴㰠㩯㹰ൽ笊⩜桜浴瑬条㔲′⼼㩯
㹰ൽ笊⩜桜浴瑬条㔱‶⼼灳湡紾桜浴牬晴素桜浴牬晴‰桜浴牬晴灜牡屽瑨汭瑲て桜浴牬晴尠慰൲尊瑨汭瑲てഠ笊⩜桜浴瑬条㈷㰠瀯紾屻尪瑨汭慴で尠慰ൽ笊⩜桜浴瑬条〱‴⼼楤㹶屽瑨汭瑲屽瑨汭瑲てഠ笊⩜桜浴瑬条‰灜牡素屻尪瑨汭慴㙧‴瀼挠慬獳∽獍乯牯慭≬紾桜浴牬晴笠桜浴牬晴‰屻尪瑨汭慴ㅧ㠴㰠灳湡猠祴敬∽潣潬㩲ㄣ㑆㜹≄紾桜浴牬晴笠桜浴牬晴‰屻尪瑨汭慴㉧㐴㰠㩯㹰ൽ笊⩜桜浴瑬条㐸☠扮灳紻桜浴牬晴尠愧尰瑨汭瑲てഠ
笊⩜桜浴瑬条㔲′⼼㩯㹰ൽ笊⩜桜浴瑬条㔱‶⼼灳湡紾桜浴牬晴素桜浴牬晴‰桜浴牬晴灜牡屽瑨汭瑲て桜浴牬晴尠慰൲尊瑨汭瑲てഠ笊⩜桜浴瑬条㈷㰠瀯紾屻尪瑨汭慴で尠慰ൽ笊⩜桜浴瑬条㘹㰠楤㹶屽瑨汭瑲屻瑨汭瑲てഠ笊⩜桜浴瑬条‰灜牡素屻尪瑨汭慴㥧‶搼癩猠祴敬∽潢摲牥渺湯㭥潢摲牥琭灯猺汯摩⌠ㅅㅅㅅㄠ〮瑰瀻摡楤杮㌺〮瑰〠湩〠湩〠湩㸢屽瑨汭瑲屻瑨汭瑲てഠ笊⩜桜浴瑬条‰灜牡素屻尪瑨汭慴㙧‴瀼挠慬獳∽獍乯牯慭≬
紾桜浴牬晴笠桜浴牬晴‰屻尪瑨汭慴㡧‴戼紾桜浴牬晴笠扜尠瑨汭瑲て䘠潲㩭屻尪瑨汭慴㥧′⼼㹢屽瑨汭瑲屽瑨汭瑲て†湁桴湯⁹⹁䜠牡慧敮敳嬠慭汩潴愺慧杲湡獥䁥牯慬摮汯睡渮瑥൝笊⩜桜浴瑬条‴灜牡素桜浴牬晴†桜浴牬晴‰屻尪瑨汭慴ㅧ㘱㰠牢紾桜浴牬晴尠楬敮桜浴牬晴‰屻尪瑨汭慴㑧尠慰ൽ笊⩜桜浴瑬条㐸㰠㹢屽瑨汭瑲屻桜浴牬晴‰敓瑮ഺ笊⩜桜浴瑬条㈹㰠戯紾桜浴牬晴素桜浴牬晴‰䘠楲慤ⱹ丠癯浥敢㠱〲㘱㌠〺‶
䵐屻尪瑨汭慴ㅧ㘱㰠牢紾桜浴牬晴尠楬敮桜浴牬晴‰屻尪瑨汭慴㑧尠慰ൽ笊⩜桜浴瑬条㐸㰠㹢屽瑨汭瑲屻桜浴牬晴‰潔ഺ笊⩜桜浴瑬条㈹㰠戯紾桜浴牬晴素桜浴牬晴‰䐠癡摩䜠敲湥屻尪瑨汭慴㡧‴氦㭴屽瑨汭瑲尼瑨汭瑲て䐠䜮敲湥䁥楣祴景慣数慣慮敶慲牯൧笊⩜桜浴瑬条㐸☠瑧紻桜浴牬晴㸠桜浴牬晴‰※慄楶楄正祥ഠ笊⩜桜浴瑬条㐸☠瑬紻桜浴牬晴㰠桜浴牬晴‰⹄楄正祥捀瑩潹捦灡捥湡癡牥污漮杲屻尪瑨汭慴㡧‴朦㭴屽瑨
汭瑲尾瑨汭瑲て㬠䨠浩䈠慥汤樨浩獀浢慬祷牥潣⥭ഠ笊⩜桜浴瑬条㐸☠瑬紻桜浴牬晴㰠桜浴牬晴‰楪䁭扳汭睡敹獲挮浯屻尪瑨汭慴㡧‴朦㭴屽瑨汭瑲尾瑨汭瑲てഠ笊⩜桜浴瑬条ㄱ‶戼㹲屽瑨汭瑲汜湩尊瑨汭瑲てഠ笊⩜桜浴瑬条‴灜牡素屻尪瑨汭慴㡧‴戼紾桜浴牬晴笠扜尠瑨汭瑲て匠扵敪瑣ഺ笊⩜桜浴瑬条㈹㰠戯紾桜浴牬晴素桜浴牬晴‰䘠㩗传歡䰠湡慖楲湡散删煥敵瑳ㄠ⼱㈲ㄯശ笊⩜桜浴瑬条㐲‴漼瀺紾屻尪瑨汭慴㉧㈵㰠漯瀺紾
桜浴牬晴灜牡屽瑨汭瑲て桜浴牬晴尠慰൲尊瑨汭瑲てഠ笊⩜桜浴瑬条㈷㰠瀯紾屻尪瑨汭慴で尠慰ൽ笊⩜桜浴瑬条〱‴⼼楤㹶屽瑨汭瑲屽瑨汭瑲てഠ笊⩜桜浴瑬条‰灜牡素屻尪瑨汭慴ㅧ㐰㰠搯癩紾桜浴牬晴素桜浴牬晴‰屻尪瑨汭慴で尠慰ൽ笊⩜桜浴瑬条㐶㰠⁰汣獡㵳䴢潳潎浲污㸢屽瑨汭瑲屻瑨汭瑲てഠ笊⩜桜浴瑬条㐲‴漼瀺紾屻尪瑨汭慴㡧‴渦獢㭰屽瑨汭瑲❜ち桜浴牬晴‰屻尪瑨汭慴㉧㈵㰠漯瀺紾桜浴牬晴灜牡屽瑨汭瑲て桜
浴牬晴尠慰൲尊瑨汭瑲てഠ笊⩜桜浴瑬条㈷㰠瀯紾屻尪瑨汭慴で尠慰ൽ笊⩜桜浴瑬条㐶㰠⁰汣獡㵳䴢潳潎浲污㸢屽瑨汭瑲屻瑨汭瑲てഠ笊⩜桜浴瑬条㐱‸猼慰瑳汹㵥挢汯牯⌺䘱㤴䐷㸢屽瑨汭瑲屻瑨汭瑲てഠ笊⩜桜浴瑬条㐲‴漼瀺紾屻尪瑨汭慴㡧‴渦獢㭰屽瑨汭瑲❜ち桜浴牬晴‰屻尪瑨汭慴㉧㈵㰠漯瀺紾屻尪瑨汭慴ㅧ㘵㰠猯慰㹮屽瑨汭瑲屽瑨汭瑲て尠瑨汭瑲屦慰絲桜浴牬晴ര尊瑨汭瑲灜牡桜浴牬晴‰屻尪瑨汭慴㝧′⼼㹰ൽ
笊⩜桜浴瑬条‰灜牡素屻尪瑨汭慴㙧‴瀼挠慬獳∽獍乯牯慭≬紾桜浴牬晴笠桜浴牬晴‰屻尪瑨汭慴㡧‴愼渠浡㵥弢慍汩湅䍤浯潰敳㸢屽瑨汭瑲筻⩜扜浫獫慴瑲䈠彍䵟楡䕬摮潃灭獯絥桜浴牬晴‰桜浴牬晴笠⩜扜浫敫摮䈠彍䵟楡䕬摮潃灭獯絥屽瑨汭瑲てഠ笊⩜桜浴瑬条㈹㰠愯紾屻尪瑨汭慴ㅧ㠴㰠灳湡猠祴敬∽潣潬㩲ㄣ㑆㜹≄紾桜浴牬晴笠桜浴牬晴‰屻尪瑨汭慴㉧㐴㰠㩯㹰ൽ笊⩜桜浴瑬条㐸☠扮灳紻桜浴牬晴尠愧尰瑨汭瑲てഠ笊⩜桜浴瑬条㔲′
⼼㩯㹰ൽ笊⩜桜浴瑬条㔱‶⼼灳湡紾桜浴牬晴素桜浴牬晴‰桜浴牬晴灜牡屽瑨汭瑲て桜浴牬晴尠慰൲尊瑨汭瑲てഠ笊⩜桜浴瑬条㈷㰠瀯紾屻尪瑨汭慴で尠慰ൽ笊⩜桜浴瑬条㘹㰠楤㹶屽瑨汭瑲屻瑨汭瑲てഠ笊⩜桜浴瑬条‰灜牡素屻尪瑨汭慴㥧‶搼癩猠祴敬∽潢摲牥渺湯㭥潢摲牥琭灯猺汯摩⌠ㅅㅅㅅㄠ〮瑰瀻摡楤杮㌺〮瑰〠湩〠湩〠湩㸢屽瑨汭瑲屻瑨汭瑲てഠ笊⩜桜浴瑬条‰灜牡素屻尪瑨汭慴㙧‴瀼挠慬獳∽獍乯牯慭≬紾桜浴牬晴笠桜浴
牬晴‰屻尪瑨汭慴㡧‴戼紾桜浴牬晴笠扜尠瑨汭瑲て䘠潲㩭屻尪瑨汭慴㥧′⼼㹢屽瑨汭瑲屽瑨汭瑲て†潄杵慬⹗䄠正牥慭൛笊⩜桜浴瑬条㐸㰠牨晥∽慭汩潴携慷歀物楷湮牯楲潣≭紾桜浴牬晴笠晜敩摬屻尪汦楤獮筴奈䕐䱒义⁋洢楡瑬㩯睤䁡楫睲湩潮牲獩挮浯索筽晜摬獲瑬捜ㅦ畜桜浴牬晴‰慭汩潴携慷歀物楷湮牯楲潣屭瑨汭瑲屽瑨汭瑲て尠瑨汭瑲屽瑨汭瑲てഠ笊⩜桜浴瑬条㈹㰠愯紾൝笊⩜桜浴瑬条‴灜牡素桜浴牬晴†桜浴牬晴‰
屻尪瑨汭慴ㅧ㘱㰠牢紾桜浴牬晴尠楬敮桜浴牬晴‰屻尪瑨汭慴㑧尠慰ൽ笊⩜桜浴瑬条㐸㰠㹢屽瑨汭瑲屻桜浴牬晴‰敓瑮ഺ笊⩜桜浴瑬条㈹㰠戯紾桜浴牬晴素桜浴牬晴‰䘠楲慤ⱹ丠癯浥敢㠱〲㘱㈠㌺‵䵐屻尪瑨汭慴ㅧ㘱㰠牢紾桜浴牬晴尠楬敮桜浴牬晴‰屻尪瑨汭慴㑧尠慰ൽ笊⩜桜浴瑬条㐸㰠㹢屽瑨汭瑲屻桜浴牬晴‰潔ഺ笊⩜桜浴瑬条㈹㰠戯紾桜浴牬晴素桜浴牬晴‰ഠ笊⩜桜浴瑬条㐸㰠牨晥∽慭汩潴挺捯慯敢捡ㅨ㌲慀汯
挮浯㸢屽瑨汭瑲屻楦汥筤⩜晜摬湩瑳䡻偙剅䥌䭎∠慭汩潴挺捯慯敢捡ㅨ㌲慀汯挮浯索筽晜摬獲瑬捜ㅦ畜桜浴牬晴‰潣潣扡慥档㈱䀳潡潣屭瑨汭瑲屽瑨汭瑲て尠瑨汭瑲屽瑨汭瑲てഠ笊⩜桜浴瑬条㈹㰠愯紾※屻尪瑨汭慴㡧‴愼栠敲㵦洢楡瑬㩯潧潦瑲䁨楣祴景慣数慣慮敶慲牯≧紾桜浴牬晴笠晜敩摬屻尪汦楤獮筴奈䕐䱒义⁋洢楡瑬㩯潧潦瑲䁨楣祴景慣数慣慮敶慲牯≧絽屻汦牤汳屴晣就汵尠瑨汭瑲てഠ笊⩜桜浴瑬条‴灜牡素潧潦瑲䁨楣
祴景慣数慣慮敶慲牯屧瑨汭瑲屽瑨汭瑲て尠瑨汭瑲屽瑨汭瑲てഠ笊⩜桜浴瑬条㈹㰠愯紾※湁桴湯⁹⹁䜠牡慧敮敳ഠ笊⩜桜浴瑬条㐸☠瑬紻桜浴牬晴㰠桜浴牬晴‰屻尪瑨汭慴㡧‴愼栠敲㵦洢楡瑬㩯条牡慧敮敳潀汲湡潤慬敮≴紾桜浴牬晴笠晜敩摬屻尪汦楤獮筴奈䕐䱒义⁋洢楡瑬㩯条牡慧敮敳潀汲湡潤慬敮≴絽屻汦牤汳屴晣就汵尠瑨汭瑲て愠慧杲湡獥䁥牯慬摮汯睡渮瑥桜浴牬晴素桜浴牬晴‰桜浴牬晴素桜浴牬晴‰屻尪瑨汭慴㥧′⼼㹡ൽ笊⩜
桜浴瑬条㐸☠瑧紻桜浴牬晴㸠桜浴牬晴‰※慐汵搠噥癩牥屻尪瑨汭慴㡧‴氦㭴屽瑨汭瑲尼瑨汭瑲てഠ笊⩜桜浴瑬条㐸㰠牨晥∽慭汩潴瀺畡䁬敧摯瑡晡潣≭紾桜浴牬晴笠晜敩摬屻尪汦楤獮筴奈䕐䱒义⁋洢楡瑬㩯慰汵杀潥慤慴汦挮浯索筽晜摬獲瑬捜ㅦ畜桜浴牬晴‰慰汵杀潥慤慴汦挮浯桜浴牬晴素桜浴牬晴‰桜浴牬晴素桜浴牬晴‰屻尪瑨汭慴㥧′⼼㹡ൽ笊⩜桜浴瑬条㐸☠瑧紻桜浴牬晴㸠桜浴牬晴‰※慄楮汥敬䴠敒敹屻尪瑨汭慴㡧‴氦
㭴屽瑨汭瑲尼瑨汭瑲てഠ笊⩜桜浴瑬条㐸㰠牨晥∽慭汩潴䐺前歀物楷湮牯楲潣≭紾桜浴牬晴笠晜敩摬屻尪汦楤獮筴奈䕐䱒义⁋洢楡瑬㩯䵄䁒楫睲湩潮牲獩挮浯索筽晜摬獲瑬捜ㅦ畜桜浴牬晴‰䵄䁒楫睲湩潮牲獩挮浯桜浴牬晴素桜浴牬晴‰桜浴牬晴素桜浴牬晴‰屻尪瑨汭慴㥧′⼼㹡ൽ笊⩜桜浴瑬条㐸☠瑧紻桜浴牬晴㸠桜浴牬晴‰屻尪瑨汭慴ㅧ㘱㰠牢紾桜浴牬晴尠楬敮桜浴牬晴‰屻尪瑨汭慴㑧尠慰ൽ笊⩜桜浴瑬条㐸㰠㹢屽瑨汭瑲屻
桜浴牬晴‰捃ഺ笊⩜桜浴瑬条㈹㰠戯紾桜浴牬晴素桜浴牬晴‰Ⱐഠ笊⩜桜浴瑬条㐸☠畱瑯紻桜浴牬晴∠桜浴牬晴‰屻尪瑨汭慴㡧‴愼栠敲㵦洢楡瑬㩯整牲汩湹潢海湡祀桡潯挮浯㈥┰挳慫桴祲敳摩汥杀慭汩挮浯㌥㭥㈥琰牥楲祬扮睯慭䁮慹潨潣㭭㈥愰牳灡䁰潡潣㭭㈥洰敯污敤橮所汥獬畯桴渮瑥┻〲⹁楂湮祥捀瑩潹捦灡捥湡癡牥污漮杲┻〲湁敧慬㈥到祡潭摮㈥┰挳湡牧祡䀸潡潣╭攳┻〲慒浹湯╤〲㌥摣畯㝧㐰䀸湩潢潣╭攳┻〲⹄汁硥湡敤䁲
楣祴景慣数慣慮敶慲牯㭧㈥䔰䰮睡潳䁮楣祴景慣数慣慮敶慲牯㭧㈥攰慶普慬杀慭汩挮浯┻〲汁捩慩㈥匰牰湩╧〲㌥慣牳灡䁰潡潣╭攳┻〲潭慥摬湥䁪敢汬潳瑵敮㭴㈥䄰杮汥╡〲慒浹湯╤〲㌥慣杮慲㡹慀汯挮浯㌥㭥㈥ⰰ㈥∰紾桜浴牬晴笠晜敩摬屻尪汦楤獮筴奈䕐䱒义⁋洢楡瑬㩯整牲汩湹潢海湡祀桡潯挮浯㈥┰挳慫桴祲敳摩汥杀慭汩挮浯㌥㭥㈥琰牥楲祬扮睯慭䁮慹潨潣㭭㈥愰牳灡䁰潡潣㭭㈥洰敯污敤橮所汥獬畯桴渮瑥┻〲⹁楂湮祥捀瑩
潹捦灡捥湡癡牥污漮杲┻〲湁敧慬㈥到祡潭摮㈥┰挳湡牧祡䀸潡潣╭攳┻〲慒浹湯╤〲㌥摣畯㝧㐰䀸湩潢潣╭攳┻〲⹄汁硥湡敤䁲楣祴景慣数慣慮敶慲牯㭧㈥䔰䰮睡潳䁮楣祴景慣数慣慮敶慲牯㭧㈥攰慶普慬杀慭汩挮浯┻〲汁捩慩㈥匰牰湩╧〲㌥慣牳灡䁰潡潣╭攳┻〲潭慥摬湥䁪敢汬潳瑵敮㭴㈥䄰杮汥╡〲慒浹湯╤〲㌥慣杮慲㡹慀汯挮浯㌥㭥㈥ⰰ㈥∰絽屻汦牤汳屴晣就汵尠瑨汭瑲て琠牥楲祬扮睯慭䁮慹潨潣൭笊⩜桜浴瑬条‴灜牡素桜浴
牬晴†桜浴牬晴‰屻尪瑨汭慴㑧†ൽ笊⩜桜浴瑬条㐸☠瑬紻桜浴牬晴㰠桜浴牬晴‰慫桴祲敳摩汥杀慭汩挮浯屻尪瑨汭慴㡧‴朦㭴屽瑨汭瑲尾瑨汭瑲て㬠琠牥楲祬扮睯慭䁮慹潨潣㭭愠牳灡䁰潡潣㭭洠敯污敤橮所汥獬畯桴渮瑥※⹁楂湮祥捀瑩潹捦灡捥湡癡牥污漮杲※湁敧慬删祡潭摮ഠ笊⩜桜浴瑬条㐸☠瑬紻桜浴牬晴㰠桜浴牬晴‰湡牧祡䀸潡潣൭笊⩜桜浴瑬条㐸☠瑧紻桜浴牬晴㸠桜浴牬晴‰※慒浹湯屻尪瑨汭慴㡧‴氦㭴屽瑨汭瑲尼
瑨汭瑲て搠畯㝧㐰䀸湩潢潣൭笊⩜桜浴瑬条㐸☠瑧紻桜浴牬晴㸠桜浴牬晴‰※⹄汁硥湡敤䁲楣祴景慣数慣慮敶慲牯㭧䔠䰮睡潳䁮楣祴景慣数慣慮敶慲牯㭧屻尪瑨汭慴㑧尠慰屽瑨汭瑲尠瑨汭瑲てഠ笊⩜桜浴瑬条‴素癥湡汦䁡浧楡潣㭭䄠楬楣灓楲杮ഠ笊⩜桜浴瑬条㐸☠瑬紻桜浴牬晴㰠桜浴牬晴‰獡慲灰慀汯挮浯屻尪瑨汭慴㡧‴朦㭴屽瑨汭瑲尾瑨汭瑲て㬠洠敯污敤橮所汥獬畯桴渮瑥※湁敧慬删祡潭摮ഠ笊⩜桜浴瑬条㐸☠瑬紻桜浴牬晴
㰠桜浴牬晴‰湡牧祡䀸潡潣൭笊⩜桜浴瑬条㐸☠瑧紻桜浴牬晴㸠桜浴牬晴‰※ബ笊⩜桜浴瑬条‴灜牡素桜浴牬晴†桜浴牬晴‰桜浴牬晴素桜浴牬晴‰桜浴牬晴素桜浴牬晴‰屻尪瑨汭慴㥧′⼼㹡ൽ笊⩜桜浴瑬条㐸☠畱瑯紻桜浴牬晴∠桜浴牬晴‰慂牲⁹⹓ഠ笊⩜桜浴瑬条㐸☠瑬紻桜浴牬晴㰠桜浴牬晴‰屻尪瑨汭慴㡧‴愼栠敲㵦洢楡瑬㩯癲敯汩畡慀汯挮浯㸢屽瑨汭瑲屻楦汥筤⩜晜摬湩瑳䡻偙剅䥌䭎∠慭汩潴爺潶楥慬䁵潡潣≭絽屻汦牤汳屴晣就汵
尠瑨汭瑲て爠潶楥慬䁵潡潣屭瑨汭瑲屽瑨汭瑲て尠瑨汭瑲屽瑨汭瑲てഠ笊⩜桜浴瑬条㈹㰠愯紾屻尪瑨汭慴㡧‴朦㭴屽瑨汭瑲尾瑨汭瑲て㬠ഠ笊⩜桜浴瑬条㐸㰠牨晥∽慭汩潴戺楮湥瑳摡䁴晣牲挮浯㸢屽瑨汭瑲屻楦汥筤⩜晜摬湩瑳䡻偙剅䥌䭎∠慭汩潴戺楮湥瑳摡䁴晣牲挮浯索筽晜摬獲瑬捜ㅦ畜桜浴牬晴‰屻尪瑨汭慴㑧尠慰扽楮湥瑳摡䁴晣牲挮浯桜浴牬晴素桜浴牬晴‰桜浴牬晴素桜浴牬晴‰屻尪瑨汭慴㥧′⼼㹡㭽猠ഠ笊⩜桜
浴瑬条㐸☠瑬紻桜浴牬晴㰠桜浴牬晴‰屻尪瑨汭慴㡧‴愼栠敲㵦洢楡瑬㩯档牡汴祥捀汦爮潣≭紾桜浴牬晴笠晜敩摬屻尪汦楤獮筴奈䕐䱒义⁋洢楡瑬㩯档牡汴祥捀汦爮潣≭絽屻汦牤汳屴晣就汵尠瑨汭瑲て挠慨瑲敬䁹晣牲挮浯桜浴牬晴素桜浴牬晴‰桜浴牬晴素桜浴牬晴‰屻尪瑨汭慴㥧′⼼㹡ൽ笊⩜桜浴瑬条㐸☠瑧紻桜浴牬晴㸠桜浴牬晴‰※慒浹湯屻尪瑨汭慴㡧‴氦㭴屽瑨汭瑲尼瑨汭瑲てഠ笊⩜桜浴瑬条㐸㰠牨晥∽慭汩潴携畯㝧㐰䀸湩
潢潣≭紾桜浴牬晴笠晜敩摬屻尪汦楤獮筴奈䕐䱒义⁋洢楡瑬㩯潤杵〷㠴楀扮硯挮浯索筽晜摬獲瑬捜ㅦ畜桜浴牬晴‰潤杵〷㠴楀扮硯挮浯桜浴牬晴素桜浴牬晴‰桜浴牬晴素桜浴牬晴‰屻尪瑨汭慴㥧′⼼㹡ൽ笊⩜桜浴瑬条㐸☠瑧紻桜浴牬晴㸠桜浴牬晴‰഻笊⩜桜浴瑬条‴灜牡素桜浴牬晴†桜浴牬晴‰屻尪瑨汭慴㡧‴愼栠敲㵦洢楡瑬㩯癥湡汦䁡浧楡潣≭紾桜浴牬晴笠晜敩摬屻尪汦楤獮筴奈䕐䱒义⁋洢楡瑬㩯癥湡汦䁡浧楡潣≭絽屻汦牤汳屴晣就
汵尠瑨汭瑲て攠慶普慬杀慭汩挮浯桜浴牬晴素桜浴牬晴‰桜浴牬晴素桜浴牬晴‰屻尪瑨汭慴㥧′⼼㹡㭽䜠湥敐牴屻尪瑨汭慴㡧‴氦㭴屽瑨汭瑲尼瑨汭瑲てഠ笊⩜桜浴瑬条㐸㰠牨晥∽慭汩潴机灣瑥敲慀汯挮浯㸢屽瑨汭瑲屻楦汥筤⩜晜摬湩瑳䡻偙剅䥌䭎∠慭汩潴机灣瑥敲慀汯挮浯索筽晜摬獲瑬捜ㅦ畜桜浴牬晴‰捧数牴䁥潡潣屭瑨汭瑲屽瑨汭瑲て尠瑨汭瑲屽瑨汭瑲てഠ笊⩜桜浴瑬条㈹㰠愯紾屻尪瑨汭慴㡧‴朦㭴屽瑨汭瑲尾瑨汭
瑲て㬠䜠潥杲睓敥浴湡⠠屻尪瑨汭慴㡧‴愼栠敲㵦洢楡瑬㩯慰瑴杹物㉬䀰楬敶挮浯㸢屽瑨汭瑲屻楦汥筤⩜晜摬湩瑳䡻偙剅䥌䭎∠慭汩潴瀺瑡祴楧汲〲〱汀癩潣≭絽屻汦牤汳屴晣就汵尠瑨汭瑲て瀠瑡祴楧汲〲〱汀癩潣屭瑨汭瑲屽瑨汭瑲て尠瑨汭瑲屽瑨汭瑲てഠ笊⩜桜浴瑬条㈹㰠愯紾ഠ笊⩜桜浴瑬条㐸☠瑬紻桜浴牬晴㰠桜浴牬晴‰屻尪瑨汭慴㡧‴愼栠敲㵦洢楡瑬㩯慰瑴杹物㉬䀰楬敶挮浯㸢屽瑨汭瑲屻楦汥筤⩜晜摬湩瑳䡻偙剅䥌䭎
∠慭汩潴瀺瑡祴楧汲〲〱汀癩潣≭絽屻汦牤汳屴晣就汵尠瑨汭瑲て瀠瑡祴楧汲〲〱汀癩潣屭瑨汭瑲屽瑨汭瑲て尠瑨汭瑲屽瑨汭瑲てഠ笊⩜桜浴瑬条㈹㰠愯紾屻尪瑨汭慴㡧‴朦㭴屽瑨汭瑲尾瑨汭瑲て㬠屻尪瑨汭慴㑧尠慰屽瑨汭瑲尠瑨汭瑲てഠ笊⩜桜浴瑬条㐸㰠牨晥∽慭汩潴栺牡祲灭捀汦爮潣≭紾桜浴牬晴笠晜敩摬屻尪汦楤獮筴奈䕐䱒义⁋洢楡瑬㩯慨牲浹䁰晣牲挮浯索筽晜摬獲瑬捜ㅦ畜桜浴牬晴‰慨牲浹䁰晣牲挮浯桜浴牬
晴素桜浴牬晴‰桜浴牬晴素桜浴牬晴‰屻尪瑨汭慴㥧′⼼㹡㭽ഠ笊⩜桜浴瑬条㐸㰠牨晥∽慭汩潴樺污牴摵䁡潡潣≭紾桜浴牬晴笠晜敩摬屻尪汦楤獮筴奈䕐䱒义⁋洢楡瑬㩯慪瑬畲慤慀汯挮浯索筽晜摬獲瑬捜ㅦ畜桜浴牬晴‰屻尪瑨汭慴㑧尠慰橽污牴摵䁡潡潣屭瑨汭瑲屽瑨汭瑲て尠瑨汭瑲屽瑨汭瑲てഠ笊⩜桜浴瑬条㈹㰠愯紾屻尪瑨汭慴ㅧ㘱㰠牢紾桜浴牬晴尠楬敮桜浴牬晴‰屻尪瑨汭慴㑧尠慰ൽ笊⩜桜浴瑬条㐸㰠㹢屽瑨汭瑲屻
桜浴牬晴‰畓橢捥㩴屻尪瑨汭慴㥧′⼼㹢屽瑨汭瑲屽瑨汭瑲て†慏慌敮嘠牡慩据敒畱獥⁴ㄱ㈯⼲㘱屻尪瑨汭慴㉧㐴㰠㩯㹰ൽ笊⩜桜浴瑬条㔲′⼼㩯㹰屽瑨汭瑲屦慰絲桜浴牬晴ര尊瑨汭瑲灜牡桜浴牬晴‰屻尪瑨汭慴㝧′⼼㹰ൽ笊⩜桜浴瑬条‰灜牡素屻尪瑨汭慴ㅧ㐰㰠搯癩紾桜浴牬晴素桜浴牬晴‰屻尪瑨汭慴で尠慰ൽ笊⩜桜浴瑬条〱‴⼼楤㹶屽瑨汭瑲屽瑨汭瑲てഠ笊⩜桜浴瑬条‰灜牡素屻尪瑨汭慴㙧‴瀼挠慬獳∽獍乯牯慭
≬紾桜浴牬晴笠桜浴牬晴‰屻尪瑨汭慴㉧㐴㰠㩯㹰ൽ笊⩜桜浴瑬条㐸☠扮灳紻桜浴牬晴尠愧尰瑨汭瑲てഠ笊⩜桜浴瑬条㔲′⼼㩯㹰屽瑨汭瑲屦慰絲桜浴牬晴ര尊瑨汭瑲灜牡桜浴牬晴‰屻尪瑨汭慴㝧′⼼㹰ൽ笊⩜桜浴瑬条‰灜牡素屻尪瑨汭慴㙧‴瀼挠慬獳∽獍乯牯慭≬紾桜浴牬晴笠桜浴牬晴‰敄牡䰠摡敩湡敇瑮敬敭㩮屻尪瑨汭慴㉧㐴㰠㩯㹰ൽ笊⩜桜浴瑬条㔲′⼼㩯㹰屽瑨汭瑲屦慰絲桜浴牬晴ര尊瑨汭瑲灜牡桜浴牬晴‰屻尪瑨汭
慴㝧′⼼㹰ൽ笊